For 2007, the average Murder Rate of Death Penalty States was 5.5, while the average Murder Rate of States without the Death Penalty was 3.1
Click on link below for breakdown.
Now a lot of things interest me about the stats. One being the obvious that clearly the death penalty is clearly no deterrent. But also the murder rates are higher in a lot of states that would describe themselves as moral Southern States as well as a lot of bible country.
But it is an interesting list as it is hard to find a thread to it. Though one thing did strike me is that with the exception of Hawaii the general rule is the hotter states have a lot more murder than the colder northern states. Now I’m sure it’s down to other factors but I would be curious with somewhere like South Dakota where it is very hot some of the year and cold another whether there is a big seasonal difference in murder rates? Quite a funny theory. Maybe it just comes down to people on a cold winters day going “I think I’ll go and murder Michael today”, then they step out into the cold and think “hmm maybe I’ll put it off till tomorrow”.
But whatever the real reason it is next time someone says the death penalty is a deterrent ask them what they base that on?